In addition to “Agatha All Along,” Kristen Anderson-Lopez and Robert Lopez were tasked with creating era-appropriate theme songs for each of the show’s decade-hopping episodes. When it came time to write “Agatha All Along,” it was originally meant to be placed in the era in which its episode “Breaking the Fourth Wall” occurs — the mid-to-late 2000s.
You might want to read this: WandaVision: What Did Elizabeth Olsen Do That She Was Asked Not To?
Anderson-Lopez told The Hollywood Reporter the show’s writers provided them with an idea called “That’s So Agatha,” a play on “That’s So Raven.” “We sort of struggled with that, [though] we loved the title,” she said. After trying a couple of variations, she said the breakthrough came when she realized there was another place to mine for inspiration, one more to do with genre than a time period.
“I think at 3 in the morning one day, I was like, ‘We should look at ‘The Addams Family’ and The Munsters.’ We should go to that witchy kind of place that TV does have a history in.'”
Once the right concept was landed upon, Anderson-Lopez said the rest of the work was easy, with the ideas quickly coming to use Hahn’s voice opposite what she calls the “Oompa Loompa” male chorus. The result reached back through the show’s own history to better tie into Agatha’s machinations in the early episodes, presenting an alternate view of the series from her perspective, all in roughly a minute.
It also became a breakout hit in its own right, leaping up the charts on iTunes and Spotify, per Cleveland.com. Now Anderson-Lopez and her husband have been nominated for an Emmy for the song, as well as their work on the actual themes.